On the same day the Oklahoma Legislature was ordered into special session by Gov. Kevin Stitt to consider reducing or eliminating personal income taxes, a report requested by the governor was released, stating that the child welfare system needs more workers, resources and salary.
Oklahomans get the government we pay for.
The Oklahoma Senate gathered on Tuesday and then quickly adjourned without picking up Stitt's request, effectively ending the session. It was right move.
This is not the time to get rid of personal income taxes, which would be estimated to take $4 billion from the state's revenue. Lawmakers already have passed various tax breaks during the past five years totaling about $750 million.
We are not against cutting taxes and have called for eliminating the state sales tax on groceries. But we urge caution after that to avoid a complete breakdown of public services.
Stitt has cited the $5 billion socked away in different savings accounts to justify income tax cuts, and he claims that Oklahomans want the cuts. He wants to "slow government down."
With the annual budget at about $11 billion, that financial cushion won't go far in the next economic storm. The savings were built up by the availability of one-time pandemic funds. Also, once a tax goes away it takes 75% approval to reinstate it, a nearly impossible bar to reach.
What Oklahomans want is a well-operating government that isn't bloated or mismanaged. Right now, state services are not flourishing, and residents are frustrated.
Oklahomans drive hours for a driver's license and wait months for a birth certificate. Public school students are crammed into overcrowded classrooms with untrained teachers. More than 9,000 high school students are on waiting lists for CareerTech workforce programs.
Mental health services remain out-of-reach for many; people with disabilities cannot obtain home-based services.
Add to this a new report finding child welfare has high staff turnover from overwork and low pay, stressed foster parents with stipends barely covering basic needs, and poor services for biological parents trying to regain custody of their children.
All these poor services may stem from a 15% reduction in state government during the past four decades while the population grew by 25%.
With more residents come more needs in infrastructure and services. It means more people driving on highways, accessing courthouses, enrolling in schools, going to parks, needing birth certificates and driver's licenses, requiring health care and even eating in restaurants that need inspections.
Oklahoma state government is at its lowest staffing level since at least 1982, when there were about 37,000 employees. Its current level is 31,487 workers.
Drastic income tax cuts originate from a supply-side, trickle-down economic theory that was tested a decade ago by Gov. Sam Brownback in Kansas. It failed.
It led to businesses using the new tax structure to protect money rather than invest in labor. The state's bond rating went down; core services and infrastructure were gutted; and the Republican-controlled Legislature was forced to raise taxes over the governor's veto.
Lawmakers would do better by setting aside tax cut talks and focusing on improving services and infrastructure.
[Editorial / Tulsa World]